St. Paul Boy

TinHay

Our son did not make it too.  but it's may be my faul because I put him in 蘇浙, so he's better with PTH & English than Cantonese.....Add Oil there are still many roads ahead...

原帖由 TungTung_daddy 於 10-10-13 13:33 發表
我個仔是3月出世。很乖，班內成績也很好。但他沒有second-in。心疼！
反而，班內一些很活躍的小孩卻有。

你們情況如何？

martse

"很乖，班內成績也很好" 入聖保羅男女的機會會大d播

martse

原帖由 TungTung_daddy 於 10-10-13 13:33 發表
我個仔是3月出世。很乖，班內成績也很好。但他沒有second-in。心疼！
反而，班內一些很活躍的小孩卻有。

你們情況如何？

TungTung_daddy

我已說了他在班內的成績很好。成績不是我評的, 是客觀的事實。

TungTung_daddy

Thanks!

It is one of the reasons the kindergarten suggested us to apply more primary schools.

funnyguy

原帖由 TungTung_daddy 於 10-10-15 11:35 發表
Thanks!

It is one of the reasons the kindergarten suggested us to apply more primary schools.

I have shared some views on your case. Do you agree with me?  ---funnyguy

MrsLaw

請問每年小學部上聖保羅書院的比率是多少？
中學部的學業成績又如何？
請指教！
謝！

hui3328

St. Paul Boys 中學及小學都是直資, 應該大部份的小學部學生可以順利升讀中學.

其中學成績一般. 在中西區中學校網, 除咗St. Paul Co-ed top of the top, Band 1 頭學校有St. Joseph, St. Stephen Girls, Bank 1 中有Ying Wah Girls, Kings, 高主教.  St. Paul Boys可能只有Band 1尾/Band 2頭.

原帖由 MrsLaw 於 10-10-15 17:22 發表
請問每年小學部上聖保羅書院的比率是多少？
中學部的學業成績又如何？
請指教！
謝！

qqmami2005

千幾個小朋友報名, 面試只有兩日.  面試後幾天很多家長巳收到失敗信. 學校真的有效率!!!!!
還是未面試巳根據家庭背境準備了這些信呢?  很難說服家長學校不是這樣做?  再者, 我和太太是基督徒, 對這學校的印像和超效率真的痛心和不認同.

amchk

可能佢地唔係選學生, 而係選家長呢!

有冇2nd in (或到時最後錄取)既人可以分享一下, 家長係咩野職業和職位!!!

cheng2

not really depended on family background. Some of the doctors' sons in class also got rejected also.

Though i am rejected also,  I found that some who got into second in are really smart and presentable.  Some of them got a lot of prizes in competition.  

原帖由 qqmami2005 於 10-10-15 23:51 發表
千幾個小朋友報名, 面試只有兩日.  面試後幾天很多家長巳收到失敗信. 學校真的有效率!!!!!
還是未面試巳根據家庭背境準備了這些信呢?  很難說服家長學校不是這樣做?  再者, 我和太太是基督徒, 對這學校的印像和超效 ...

hui3328

算啦, 呢間嘢無論成績, 校際比賽都唔係至Top學校, 面試又做得咁求其, 如果你住中西區/灣仔, 不如參加統一派位, 好多官津校都好過佢.

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-10-13 14:05 發表
yes, it is sad, but unfortunately it is a fact.  Your choices are, either playing according to the rules of the game (i.e. the whole P1 admission process), or leave the system and find your own way, e ...

feliciak

我想請問rejection信係咪有分兩款? 一款係明年七月可以再interview過(re-consider), 而另一款係完全冇希望呢?

cheng2

So, which one is better than it?

Government school: St Joseph
Private school: St Co-edu

Other than the above two, I can't find other.  But, one is difficult to get it (st paul co-edu), the other has hard workload and you have to try very hard to keep in the top in class in order to go to st joseph secondary.    So, apart from the above two, I still think st paul boys primary school  is the good choice, though i was rejected.

原帖由 hui3328 於 10-10-16 10:08 發表
算啦, 呢間嘢無論成績, 校際比賽都唔係至Top學校, 面試又做得咁求其, 如果你住中西區/灣仔, 不如參加統一派位, 好多官津校都好過佢.

hui3328

灣仔區可考慮軒呢詩官小, 據聞有七成入皇仁. 華仁也不錯, 雖然近年成績跌得好勁, 不過都應該好過St. Paul Boys.

另外, 你可參考去年的一些Post, 高主教中學的成績及Banding都好過St. Paul Boys.

原帖由 cheng2 於 10-10-16 12:29 發表
So, which one is better than it?

Government school: St Joseph
Private school: St Co-edu

Other than the above two, I can't find other.  But, one is difficult to get it (st paul co-edu), the other has ...

cheng2

But Wah Yan is not good academically both in primary and secondary.  Besides, it seems that the
brand name of st paul boys is better than the other primary schools you suggested and the family
background of the students are totally different.  St Paul boys is more middle class, has a long
history  .  Though the the secondary school face some difficulty now, i thought that it will be good after 6 years when our kids are promoted to secondary
school.

   

原帖由 hui3328 於 10-10-16 12:46 發表
灣仔區可考慮軒呢詩官小, 據聞有七成入皇仁. 華仁也不錯, 雖然近年成績跌得好勁, 不過都應該好過St. Paul Boys.

另外, 你可參考去年的一些Post, 高主教中學的成績及Banding都好過St. Paul Boys.


...

diversity

[quote]原帖由 hui3328 於 10-10-16 10:08 發表
算啦, 呢間嘢無論成績, 校際比賽都唔係至Top學校, 面試又做得咁求其, 如果你住中西區/灣仔, 不如參加統一派位, 好多官津校都好過佢.

你呢隻嘢無論講嘢或作嘢都令人覺得你係一pat嘢!!

syshawn

你話個面試求其，俾兩日時間你地好唔好！我反而欣賞用二十分鐘可以表現自己嘅小朋友

ukodelechan

其實我唔明點會覺得間學校唔好，但又要報？間間名校都成日俾人傳成績差，唔好等等。。。我覺得謠言止於智者，學校好唔好搵下資料都知，何況學校唔好，唔top，又點會有千幾人報，爭崩頭呢？
我覺得小朋友考唔到好正常，始終考生多過學位幾倍，但可以做番小小檢討，下次有進步，唔應該詆毀學校。。。

joan921

原帖由 qqmami2005 於 10-10-15 23:51 發表
千幾個小朋友報名, 面試只有兩日.  面試後幾天很多家長巳收到失敗信. 學校真的有效率!!!!!
還是未面試巳根據家庭背境準備了這些信呢?  很難說服家長學校不是這樣做?  再者, 我和太太是基督徒, 對這學校的印像和超效 ...

咪作嘢啦......大家都係6號嗰日或之後先收到信.....6號之前都無聽到有家長收到消息....已經有好叻的小朋友話考唔到, 亦都有無宗教背景的小朋友可以2nd in ...咁有幾唔公平......