小一入學面試有筆試是否違反教局規定?

motherotk

有哪一间小學面試用筆試?

Geni

原帖由 ysnmama 於 10-11-8 15:58 發表
其實如何介定什麼是"實力"?  

好問題!! 我諗唔同學校同唔同家長都有自己o既標準, 亦都係因為大家o既準則唔同, 所以時不時都會出現o個d乜乜學校收生唔公平, 乜乜學校黑箱作業o既topic..... 呢一兩個月會係呢類topic o既高峰期.

ysnmama

其實如何介定什麼是"實力"?  

原帖由 Geni 於 10-11-8 15:15 發表
學校選擇做直資, 主要原因係有收生權, 有得揀學生. 而家長放棄免費教育去考直資, 係因為唔想靠運, 想靠自己小朋友o既"實力"考入一d學生同家長都經過揀選o既學校. 各取所需而已.

至於用乜o野方法去揀學生, 間間都有 ...

ysnmama

I have interested to know how DBSPD and SPCC to pick their "right" kids too. thanks.

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-11-5 08:34 發表
Even DBS don't have the written test??How does DBS screen, when my first child go through DBS, St Paul Co-ed  interview, I am very clear on what are the criteria they were having without any written t ...

Geni

學校選擇做直資, 主要原因係有收生權, 有得揀學生. 而家長放棄免費教育去考直資, 係因為唔想靠運, 想靠自己小朋友o既"實力"考入一d學生同家長都經過揀選o既學校. 各取所需而已.

至於用乜o野方法去揀學生, 間間都有自己o既準則, 總之有辦法揀到佢想要o既學校就係o勒! 其實好多學校都冇用筆試來考學生, 一來教育局suggest, 二來邊得o黎咁得閒改幾千份卷, 但就算唔係用筆試, 佢地一樣有大把唔係個個小朋友都適合o既揀選方法o既嗻~~

總之, 考學校, 靠o既係"實力"+"關係"+"運氣", 缺一不可.

huba

Are you really sure about the selection criteria for DBSPD & SPCCPS? Or you just meant you know there is no written test.

原帖由 motherotk 於 5/11/2010 08:34 發表
Even DBS don't have the written test??How does DBS screen, when my first child go through DBS, St Paul Co-ed  interview, I am very clear on what are the criteria they were having without any written t ...

flostangraphy

were these schools scanning the parents instead?
mind to share more about that?

原帖由 motherotk 於 5/11/2010 08:34 發表
Even DBS don't have the written test??How does DBS screen, when my first child go through DBS, St Paul Co-ed  interview, I am very clear on what are the criteria they were having without any written t ...

fotk

Not every "smartest kid" will choose TSL when final results are released...most will go to SPCC, DGS, DBS or even Kowloon Tong Primary school and other comparable private school with better secondary school allocations...

Check the P6 allocation, most private schools in Kowloon Tong are having much better allocation results than TSL..

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 10-11-5 20:05 發表
我完全不知道其他三校的情況. 我的意思是那麼多人報陳守仁,學校怎可能不用盡方法來找出文武全才的孩子來呢.

yuengooluk

我完全不知道其他三校的情況. 我的意思是那麼多人報陳守仁,學校怎可能不用盡方法來找出文武全才的孩子來呢.

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-11-5 08:31 發表
what are their criteria?? can you share more?? Same as DBS? Same as DGS??? Same as SPaul Coed??

fotk

SO...? what's the differences?

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-11-5 08:44 發表
BTW, have you informed that:

Kowloon Tong Primary School is a private one and SFS is a private school

TSL & GT is a DSS school with subvention from the government and using our tax payer's money...
...

motherotk

BTW, have you informed that:

Kowloon Tong Primary School is a private one and SFS is a private school

TSL & GT is a DSS school with subvention from the government and using our tax payer's money...

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-11-5 08:34 發表
Even DBS don't have the written test??How does DBS screen, when my first child go through DBS, St Paul Co-ed  interview, I am very clear on what are the criteria they were having without any written t ...

motherotk

Even DBS don't have the written test??How does DBS screen, when my first child go through DBS, St Paul Co-ed  interview, I am very clear on what are the criteria they were having without any written test...

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-11-5 08:31 發表
what are their criteria?? can you share more?? Same as DBS? Same as DGS??? Same as SPaul Coed??

motherotk

what are their criteria?? can you share more?? Same as DBS? Same as DGS??? Same as SPaul Coed??

原帖由 yuengooluk 於 10-11-4 20:45 發表
my gut feeling is if TSL doesn't use such criteria, how can they screen 150 children out of >3800 applicants?

huba

I am not a parent of YW student. Yet, I am curious about why you made the below comment.

Can you share more?

原帖由 wanmum 於 3/11/2010 17:20 發表

Agreed!  Ying Wa is an example.

yuengooluk

my gut feeling is if TSL doesn't use such criteria, how can they screen 150 children out of >3800 applicants?

原帖由 fotk 於 10-11-4 00:13 發表
My opinions:

Both are good Yes Or No

From this year's interview as told by my kid on the process of interviews,

TSL is going to be the same as 九龍塘學校 in terms of :

1) asking academically "sou ...

yuengooluk

can you pls elaborate? i want to know more.  thx.

原帖由 wanmum 於 10-11-3 17:20 發表

Agreed!  Ying Wa is an example.

[ 本帖最後由 yuengooluk 於 10-11-4 20:46 編輯 ]

motherotk

I heard about that, but my kid does not apply this school, can you elaborate what have you experienced??

原帖由 wanmum 於 10-11-3 17:20 發表

Agreed!  Ying Wa is an example.

Ewongmum

really ? that is no good.  SFA used to be a school that I may consider.

原帖由 sylam28 於 10-11-3 19:35 發表
上年,SFA有考筆試,是我女兒說的,考成45MINS,又不讓考生用學校厠所,學校只提供臨時膠TOLIET,安排十分差,對這間學校十分反感.

fotk

That's terrible, sorry to hear that...

原帖由 sylam28 於 10-11-3 19:35 發表
上年,SFA有考筆試,是我女兒說的,考成45MINS,又不讓考生用學校厠所,學校只提供臨時膠TOLIET,安排十分差,對這間學校十分反感.

fotk

My opinions:

Both are good Yes Or No

From this year's interview as told by my kid on the process of interviews,

TSL is going to be the same as 九龍塘學校 in terms of :

1) asking academically "sound" questions in interviews

2) targeting at "excellently smart" kids that are academic and achievement oriented

Good for some kids (the 150 selected ones), Definitely Disaster for Other kids (Unfortunately, yet may be lucky of not being selected, thanks God!!)

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-3 18:44 發表
Can you elaborate:

1. whether all DSS/subvented schools are not practising it (if not all, can you give some examples?);

2. in what way are they not practising it?