放棄 SPC 選 港同, 會有人支持我嗎?

SaSaMummy

This is not the case.
My girl in SPC P 4.  She came from SPK.
The homework is very reasonable and the examination for three subjects (Chinese, English and Maths) only.
Teachers keep on telling them don't go to 補習.   There's teachers available to take care of kids until 6pm.
My girl has difficult on Chinese only. All other subjects are fine with her.  
She likes the school very much.
Of course there's a lot of smart and outstanding girls in the school but that's not my girl.
For your case, you know your girl much more than others.  I am sure that your choice is the best choice for your girl.

原帖由 jdepp 於 10-11-30 14:16 發表
如果得 60 分, 聽聞老師都會叫你去補習喇~~~

easydad

At the end of the day, we all have our priorities.
I gave up DBSPD last year.  My son is now in HKUGA and I am very pleased I made that decision.  (I have a daughter to follow.  Plus, I was disgusted by the snobbishness of some schools.)
Just pick the school you feel best for your kid is good.  We need not get endorsements from everyone.

weisscarton

我女讀SPC到今日我同個女都唔明點解同學要上補習班。唔識老師可以問，成績差有老師會放學幫你，教你。表面上是四＋人一班，但好多科目是分兩組是兩個老師，二＋人一班。只要肯考試前温書，所有 notes讀一次，根本無可能唔合格。你要一百分當然要多閱讀課外書。功課量適中，同學關係好。希望你同女兒再商量一下。

weisscarton

原帖由 goo_littlebb 於 10-11-30 14:00 發表
如果家長真係俾到好多時間陪佢溫書做功課, 我相信補習唔係必須既, 佢既壓力比起好多名校其實都係少左.
而且學校雖說只係要求係60分, 只係家長想自己小朋友拎90-100分 (呢個係校長講既), 但當你乜都唔做而佢拎60分,  ...

我女每次考試前一星期先温書，每日唔會多個兩個鐘做功課。

Naurto

書名叫"九型人格教育". 粉紅色的, 可在商務買.

好少人會用性格選學校的. 其實性格的發展在小學時尤為重要。現今的教育制度只是複制機械人, 每個學生都有差不多相同的 cert, 相同的學歷 VTC 如是, 大學如是，你要想的是怎樣把你兒子的獨有潛力發揮出來才是最重要.., 九型人格可以幫你看清你和你子女的陰暗面...只是個人意見分享

Pumpkin_mama

我估你心目中已有答案
你選邊間我都會支持你喎
不過就要考慮清楚問多D人意見,或者可以問下老師/清楚2間運作既朋友.始終SPC係一間出名好既學校,而港同都比較新.
比我..你都知我 一定SPC...

newbkmember

I would absolutely vote for SPC! Happy learning (among all traditional schools), good foundation and good secondary school back up.
You're comparing with apple and orange for SPC & 港同

tvnotallow

SPC is a really good school, girl loves to go to school.  Good reading and learning environment.

jdepp

You're right.

原帖由 easydad 於 10-11-30 15:19 發表
At the end of the day, we all have our priorities.
I gave up DBSPD last year.  My son is now in HKUGA and I am very pleased I made that decision.  (I have a daughter to follow.  Plus, I was disgusted  ...

jdepp

請問你係咪 ftm?

你個女係咪坐定定乖巧形呢?

所有 notes讀一次，根本無可能唔合格。<== 即係讀晒學校教既野就有保證合格, rite?
只係想高d 分先要出去補習 or 自己學d extra 野?
咁係咪學校考試會出d 課外野呢?

sorry 咁多問題!!

原帖由 weisscarton 於 10-11-30 16:47 發表
我女讀SPC到今日我同個女都唔明點解同學要上補習班。唔識老師可以問，成績差有老師會放學幫你，教你。表面上是四＋人一班，但好多科目是分兩組是兩個老師，二＋人一班。只要肯考試前温書，所有 notes讀一次，根本無可能唔合格。你要 ...

jdepp

多謝你, 我會用黎參考~

原帖由 Naurto 於 10-11-30 23:43 發表
書名叫"九型人格教育". 粉紅色的, 可在商務買.

好少人會用性格選學校的. 其實性格的發展在小學時尤為重要。現今的教育制度只是複制機械人, 每個學生都有差不多相同的 cert, 相同的學歷 VTC 如是, 大學如是，你要想的 ...

jdepp

鍚晒你

原帖由 Pumpkin_mama 於 10-12-1 00:56 發表
我估你心目中已有答案
你選邊間我都會支持你喎
不過就要考慮清楚問多D人意見,或者可以問下老師/清楚2間運作既朋友.始終SPC係一間出名好既學校,而港同都比較新.
比我..你都知我 一定SPC... ...

Pumpkin_mama

agree 中學都係一個好重要既issue...spcs聽講收番9成,如中英數冇唔合格.

原帖由 天瑜 於 10-12-1 07:29 發表
我選小學的同時，會考慮中學條路。
我其實喜歡SPCS(中學部)多D!  (DREAM SCHOOL 太PERFECT了!)
我不嬲都認為小學所學的知識係用來打底，所以傳統教學係絕對冇問題!
如果係我，我一定選SPCS(小學部)，我們心目中的DREAM SCHOO ...

weisscarton

請問你係咪 ftm?

你個女係咪坐定定乖巧形呢?

所有 notes讀一次，根本無可能唔合格。<== 即係讀晒學校教既野就有保證合格, rite?
只係想高d 分先要出去補習 or 自己學d extra 野?
咁係咪學校考試會出d 課外野呢?


1.
我不是 ftm.
我要返工，但我初小時都會幫手檢查功課，默書，檢查書包。高小就佢自已攪掂，有唔識先問，默書自已默，考試會幫手問佢問題。到高年班角色是聆聽者，每日返屋企都會講學校發生事，有開心，有唔開心，但通常都開心事。每日最開心事就是返學。
2.
我女應該唔係坐定定乖巧形，亦不是勤力讀書形。典形 St Paul 形，上堂時留心，別人發言要聆聽，玩時玩，享樂時享樂，考試時讀書。
3.
首先你要明白點解香港班家長要補習，大部份人都希望小朋友考頭幾名，有獎，但 St Paul 是每年都會將小朋友轉唔同班，希望小朋友認識唔同朋友，學習同人相處，同明白不是自己好叻，一山還有一山高。
我自己發覺補習過頭的那班小朋友，通常上堂唔專心，靠補習社温習，有時温過期 notes,
結果自已的 notes就無温，就會好低分。要考高分不是要出去補習，正確是閱讀，看英文台節目。大部份學校近年模式都是閱讀理解佔很重分，多閱讀先會成績好。作文同寫日記要有生活經驗，每曰都困在家根本上寫不到好文章，最後又是補習。我會覺得無論你揀那一間學校，最重要是教導小朋友正確讀書態度，每日和小朋友溝通，假曰多户外活動，自然不用補習。否則就算讀國際學校，我都見唔少人中英數都補。

仔仔錫錫你

所謂好學校得兩種 : 公認性 & 自己覺得
如果我話spc 係公認好學校應該無咩人會質疑, 亦都好難搵到多過3間dds/私小好過佢.  不過如果學校唔係小朋友果隻type, 就算讀女拔都會覺得欠缺d野.  

相反搵到間合適的小學, even 學校公認性無咁多人認同, 但只要小朋友讀得開心就係好學校.  大人做工moutivation 主要係$$; 小朋友返學個moutivation 係開心, 讀得唔開心又點會成績好.  所以如果覺得HKUGA合適就go ahead. 十卞十卞!!

goo_littlebb

同意, 我地又唔係樓主, 相信佢做呢個決定一啲都唔易, 家長俾得自己個女入SPN/SPK, 終極目標都係SPC, 你估考SPN/SPK易咩, 爭崩頭架~但入小學, 要考慮好多野, 因長遠仲要考慮埋中學, 成12年既學習, 都想搵間夾到小朋友性格既學校...

原帖由 仔仔錫錫你 於 10-12-1 14:51 發表
所謂好學校得兩種 : 公認性 & 自己覺得
如果我話spc 係公認好學校應該無咩人會質疑, 亦都好難搵到多過3間dds/私小好過佢.  不過如果學校唔係小朋友果隻type, 就算讀女拔都會覺得欠缺d野.  

相反搵到間合適的小學, e ...

DeeDeeY

Just to share with you:

My girl is now a K3 student of SPK and will go to SPC next year.
Before we received the acceptance letter from SPC, we also applied for HKUGA and had attended the 1st part of the first interview.
We didn’t go to the 2nd part after receiving the acceptance letter.
Personally, I like SPC much much more than HKUGA.

My girl is active and talkative.
I think in her class teacher’s eye, she is naughty.
I felt down and was frustrated every time after receiving the negative comment from her teacher during the parent’s day.
In fact, I was really worried that she cannot get a seat in SPC but luckily she did.

I always ask myself a question: does traditional school like SPC really suit her?
Some SPC parents said primary school life is hard and exams are difficult but some said this is a happy school.
There is nothing conclusive because every girl is unique.
You will never get the answer until your girl finally be a P1 student there.
I don’t think all the students in SPC are quiet and lady-like but indeed, most of the SPC girls I met are cheerful, active and confident.
So it doesn’t mean that SPC is not suitable to active girl, right?

Being a student there for nearly 3 years, my girl really loves the school and treasures the friendship she has built up with her classmates, and certainly she loves her beautiful summer uniform.

tvnotallow:
I know your girl got the offer from DGJS last year, would you mind telling me your final decision and the reason behind?

weisscarton

我留言是希望家長唔好誤會學校是傳统學校，學校是好少抄寫，六年級每次都是寫一板字，每個字寫幾次。唔會時常背默，一年可能得幾次。高年級英文閱讀理解是深，但是目的是要你查字典，你做完錯都無人鬧你，不過你要改正。學校要小朋友閱讀，學習上網自已找資料，找答案。無人會知你考試幾多分，除非你自已講，老師唔會當小朋友面講你幾多分。
你有困難可以打電話比老師，社工，同 sister講。