有冇人會放棄聖心offer呢?

mary1004

多謝Ian, 你真係好西利, 好熱心, 請保重身體, 多謝你既細心分析(ABCD朋友逐一分析), 我又成為左你的Fans

之前我既諗法好表面, 淨係單為了唔想小朋友升學問題而煩,諗深一層,其實我覺得要小朋友學懂包容和感恩比成績好更難,自己會比較鐘意能夠重視與家長溝通的學校,因為我個女而家返既PG,我每日係課室出面睇閉路電視觀察佢,老師又會比好多意見同耐心聽我地教小朋友遇到既問題,等佢放學既時候又可以同其他家長分享我地教小朋友既方法,就係因為咁,我先更清楚了解自己既小朋友,呢樣野對我真係好重要,呢間PG就好似變成左我既助手一樣

其實我都覺得校工好有愛心(唔係因為笑容)->因為上次Interview完之後我個女自己去洗手間見到校工,佢見我個女識用腦諗下個水龍頭係有紅外線感應,用隻手去惦下個紅外線位,佢又讚下我個女.我個女好有自信咁出番黎,校工都咁識同小朋友溝通,真利害!

其實我係第二個post話其他學校interview做得好, 唔係想話SHCK做得唔夠好, 因為那間學校申請人無咁多,好似得七百幾,咁佢地當然有咁多資源去做多D,我覺得去完SHCK既interview,感覺好好,問既問題一樣(問白菜,我個女都唔識答,佢見到個切切玩具係茄瓜,佢話係辣椒, 都收左佢AM,可見答得岩唔岩唔係真係咁重要,老師問小朋友既問題一致),過程流暢(我地下午兩點IN都係等左5分鐘)

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-2-17 07:42 AM 發表
That's a lot of questions especially I used lots of energy and courage to reply the last one.....  let me try my best before I head back to my sick bed



The reason to explain the low percentage of M ...

mirage2007

spk的小朋友真的好忙,見到他們放學後都要去呢度去果度補習同返興趣班,(我也是住在附近),每位家長都要為p1學位角力, 所以k1已經要不停催谷學生...競爭p1學位

這樣子真的辛苦,但這樣訓練出來的小孩子,可能真的容易在社會生存...

AhBoMama

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-2-17 07:03 發表
Sorry that have been very sick and had high fever (38.8C) so I had slept 12 hours straight.  Just wake up and feel better now.

Honestly, the topic is so sensitive that I guess not many people would r ...

Being an old girl of SH, I totally agree :D
I aslo applied SPK (as it is really a Good school) for my girl but she refused to get into the classroom on that day (may be cos' of the tense atmosphere that morning) and ....finally, I qave up the interview and left......

And the truth is , SHCK is more suitable for my girl, like her mom :D

iantsang

SPK or SHCK?

If SHCK, all of them are parents-volunteer.

原帖由 Cutemom0808 於 11-2-17 10:22 發表


交表當天座在房內收表的有部份看似是家長義工

iantsang

hahaha, Tbaby!  I have no guts to go that far to comment on that.  But indeed this is something I wanna say but held back.

As I said, I have a close relative who is current SPCS student.  I just miss her laugh so much for years.  Now can hardly see her teeth.....

原帖由 Tbaby 於 11-2-17 10:42 發表
(別介意少少離題)

本人亦比較過SPK同SHCK的其中一個分別

如果細心留意, 大部份SHCK, St clare, 真光的學生明顯會開心,昂起頭走路 ; 而見到大部份SPK的同學仔(本人工作地點在SPK附近) ,毫無表情, 默默跟著工人姐姐 ...

iantsang

hi mary1004,

haha, another fans?  Thank you first for your appreciation.

Don't say that, actually their P1 promotion is only one of the many factors that we can use as criteria.  Whether someone would consider it as important or not, totally up to any individual.  Like myself, I guess I put this a much higher priority two years ago.  However, now I would learn to appreciate the love and care from the teachers since I just cannot imagine someone can really care so much for our children.

However, I must remind you this.  The teachers at SHCK are rather busy (extremely busy indeed) as they already spent a lot of time in the kindergarten (especially with the longer school hours).  So, please do not expect them to call you the way like many other kindergartens or pre-nurseries.  In order to communicate with them, you may write a note to them and they may either return you a note or phone you up if really needed.  Or you can talk to them when you pick up the kids.  Please be really considerate to them as as parents, I don't want them to receive too much pressures as they have already done a lot for the kids.

Concerning the interview, actually I didn't know you have commented about another kindergarten at all (or I cannot remember anymore, sorry).  Honestly, always open for criticism if there are anything that the kindergarten can do better, certainly in a reasonable manner.

Ian

原帖由 mary1004 於 11-2-17 11:24 發表
多謝Ian, 你真係好西利, 好熱心, 請保重身體, 多謝你既細心分析(ABCD朋友逐一分析), 我又成為左你的Fans

之前我既諗法好表面, 淨係單為了唔想小朋友升學問題而煩,諗深一層,其實我覺得要小朋友學懂包容和感恩比 ...

iantsang

I guess that must be true.  No pain no gain.  So they totally deserve being such a popular choice!

原帖由 mirage2007 於 11-2-17 11:48 發表
spk的小朋友真的好忙,見到他們放學後都要去呢度去果度補習同返興趣班,(我也是住在附近),每位家長都要為p1學位角力, 所以k1已經要不停催谷學生...競爭p1學位

這樣子真的辛苦,但這樣訓練出來的小孩子,可能真的容易在 ...

iantsang

So you are the one who didn't attend the interview at the end?  Sorry just answered too many posts this week.

For our elder daughter, we took two weeks time to convince her to go to SPK for interview.  It's because the moment she finished SHCK interview, she was so sure that she will get the offer that she thinks there are no needs to go to another one!  (And obviously she had made the choice for herself already)  But indeed, the environment itself feels quite pressurized.  I guess, at least for me, we are not that level of parents to fight for the very best.

原帖由 AhBoMama 於 11-2-17 12:04 發表



Being an old girl of SH, I totally agree :D
I aslo applied SPK (as it is really a Good school) for my girl but she refused to get into the classroom on that day (may be cos' of the tense atmosphere ...

AhBoMama

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-2-17 13:56 發表
So you are the one who didn't attend the interview at the end?  Sorry just answered too many posts this week.

For our elder daughter, we took two weeks time to convince her to go to SPK for interview ...

Dear Ian,
Yes, same feeling as you....too pressurized for me too....and my daughter and I had made a good decision of not attending the interview ...

Best wishes to all new Sacred Heartists !!

AhBoMama

aidalau

Ian, 你好.我都一路有睇你的文章.知道你囡囡之前都收到St Clare嘅offer, 想問下你如何比較佢同SHCK?SHCK應該唔係一條龍,上小學是否比較麻煩?我知佢上午班是私家, 你知唔唔佢嘅收生條件?下午班是津貼,即要自行收生或大抽獎. 點解最後放棄一條龍嘅ST CLARE?

iantsang

No, we never applied for St. Clare's.  And they also don't guarantee P1 admission when we applied for the elder one.  They only started to guarantee this couple years.

原帖由 aidalau 於 11-2-17 15:48 發表
Ian, 你好.我都一路有睇你的文章.知道你囡囡之前都收到St Clare嘅offer, 想問下你如何比較佢同SHCK?SHCK應該唔係一條龍,上小學是否比較麻煩?我知佢上午班是私家, 你知唔唔佢嘅收生條件?下午班是津貼,即要自行收生或 ...

yaubama

我諗我可能要放棄讀聖心,因為女女原本婆婆照顧,住香港,但婆婆現在不方便照顧,要比嫲嫲照顧,我倆又唔放心請工人睇。所以要搬返嫲嫲大圍度住。真係好唔想，但我估都無可能有褓姆車由大圍到聖心，其實如果有車由九龍搪去都可行。真係唔知可唔可以揾到褓姆車啱我地嘅需要。

iantsang

Actually I remember that were 1-2 families which mentioned they are living in Shatin and we did propose Kowloon Tong/ Shatin as one of the pickup points to see so that's how we find them out.  However, the number is just too small so it is far away from forming a route for the school bus.

No need to give up on nanny buses, even though you may not find one which takes SHCK only, but there may be other nanny buses which may take students from Tai Wai to HK side, good luck!

原帖由 yaubama 於 11-2-17 18:44 發表
我諗我可能要放棄讀聖心,因為女女原本婆婆照顧,住香港,但婆婆現在不方便照顧,要比嫲嫲照顧,我倆又唔放心請工人睇。所以要搬返嫲嫲大圍度住。真係好唔想，但我估都無可能有褓姆車由大圍到聖心，其實如果有車由九龍搪去都 ...

aidalau

咁我記錯了.依家都唔知點選, St Clare一條龍, P1唔使煩;但聖心又係一間好好嘅學校,好似唔會有人為St Clare而放棄聖心, 請你比D意見.

lovelinda

我諗我都好可能會放棄聖心,因為真是太遠啦,仲要係半山,交通又無spk咁方便,我們(暫時)都應該唔會考慮搬到港島........最主要是因為細佬.......不過我都仲係1516,仲未決定到.......

vlui55

hahaha....Ian, you are rite, i have a big question mark in my mind too...hahaha

vlui55

true true cutemon0808, 100% agree with your point. I can feel parents from SH are filled with heart and seems willing to share, and less competitive or maybe in a more gentle way!

原帖由 Cutemom0808 於 11-2-16 16:12 發表


都不是個個喜歡SPK，如果我有幸有offer我都要問清楚是否真的合適。例如SH家長熱心助人又細心已是一個很吸引人的地方。

vlui55

yes yes yes!!!!agree!

原帖由 angrybirds 於 11-2-16 18:29 發表



我諗好少人會只係報一間幼稚園，如果sp出結果先，一樣會有d人(可能會少d)hold住而等sh出結果

iantsang

It's a bit difficult a comparison but let me try to ask back the following question, based on the concerns you have stated.

If you like St. Clare's primary school and this is what you want and suitable for your daughter, then I think it is reasonable to take St. Clare's.

If this is not the case, then you will have to ask yourself how much risks are you willing to take, or you feel justify to take, for letting your daughter enter SHCK.

Frankly I am really not in a position to tell you which one you choose.  But my wife and I had made the decision for ourselves to give up another full one-dragon for our young one, to go to SHCK.  For us, we understand it is still more important to let her go to a kindergarten which we feel she would learn the proper values and educated with our expectation.  But I cannot say this on behalf of others so you would have to decide on your own.

原帖由 aidalau 於 11-2-17 19:17 發表
咁我記錯了.依家都唔知點選, St Clare一條龍, P1唔使煩;但聖心又係一間好好嘅學校,好似唔會有人為St Clare而放棄聖心, 請你比D意見.

vlui55

Ian, i have one question, do you know how the school SH assigned the kid to either AM or PM sessions? as I saw some parents said that her girl may not be able to answer all question but still got AM offer, I really envy and congr to them! hahaha!

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-2-17 13:41 發表
hahaha, Tbaby!  I have no guts to go that far to comment on that.  But indeed this is something I wanna say but held back.

As I said, I have a close relative who is current SPCS student.  I j ...