德望 vs聖保祿:那間學業成績較出色

siden

可以告訴我嗎？我都覺得迷惑，德望的成績不像太差，但那些什麼report 又話入大學率大跌。有冇德小高年級的家長提供第一手資料？
我估下，會唔會係德小primary 其實幾好，有d似maryknoll. 但因為升中時冇左selection mechanism, 好似maryknoll 升中唔係band one嘅就out, 所以中學成績拉低了。加上近年中學又走左好多好老師。
請賜教

siden

Since ＞90% GH primary sudden go to secondary, some of the students academically should not be band 1. You can't imagine >90% GH primary students are band 1 right?
And some of the top students may leave due to reasons as mentioned by Ian. So overall the GH secondary result may not be great.
However, GH music/sports achievement are certainly better than SPC. They are comparable to DGS in these non academic aspect.

Thanks Ian for your analysis.

siden

I agree with Ian.

I really think SPC is better than GH, but I don't think the difference is that great to be 差幾班，唔同級。

如果小女有幸入讀GH primary, 又發下夢她名列前茅（Ian 唔好嬲我借個forum 發夢），我絕對會俾小女去interview 插班HY/St Mary 等津校。就算負擔得到，我不是富豪，想儲多點$，有間有質素的津校收，我會飛撲去。

GH kg 收了小女，我很感恩，但未必會讀。因為我不會太計較那間famous 或high grade, 我要的是最適合孩子和自己家庭的一間。入了不high grade 的又怎樣？誰說入了最high grade 的就最上等？只要小女在純樸environment 中長大，academic中上就ok。

贊同大家make comments時可以持平一點。