派不到M1 或M2數

snowbell

唔好放棄，試試同校方聯絡，可不可以在校讀M1.

一日未開學, 還有變數.

Sorry, 忘記了文憑試的科目, 除公開試的分數再加學校平時分, 所以無得自修.

看來比會考更無彈度.

[ 本帖最後由 snowbell 於 11-7-21 16:03 編輯 ]

ANChan59

原帖由 snowbell 於 11-7-21 10:20 發表
唔好放棄，試試同校方聯絡，可不可以在校讀或自修M1. (學校行政都要有彈度)

有些學生只派maths core, 但出外補習社修M1, 再報考試.

一日未開學, 還有變數. ...

I assume M1 also need continuous assessment, how can a tuition centre provide that??? My assumption is valid or not??

gigivinda

原帖由 mak 於 11-7-21 00:51 發表
現在只有希望他盡量讀好phy,chem,biog 這3科,到時可以入到大學,

哎呀，真是忍不住要出句聲，不是大學收了就夠，要在大學讀得自在才成，也要大學畢業以后考專業試得心應手才成。沒有了calculus （M1/M2), Econ, Finance, Accounting, Physics, Insurance etc 都會讀得吃力。建議：不考試也要自修。

mio8390

多數是選數學科的前60名或80名，要看看每班收學生多少，當然是成績好的學生選擇M1或M2先。

原帖由 漢堡飽 於 11-7-21 10:03 發表


同意！

snowbell

很有道理!  
學問永遠是自己.

等於讀醫無話要Bio, 但有學過Bio在學習上某方面又好些.

原帖由 gigivinda 於 11-7-21 13:52 發表


哎呀，真是忍不住要出句聲，不是大學收了就夠，要在大學讀得自在才成，也要大學畢業以后考專業試得心應手才成。沒有了calculus （M1/M2), Econ, Finance, Accounting, Physics, Insurance etc 都會讀得吃力。建議：不考試也要 ...

snowbell

如果剛巧自己讀那級勁人多，豈不爭M1,M2爭得你死我活, 合資格讀M1,M2有90人, 而得80個位, 最後那10人點算?  

原帖由 mio8390 於 11-7-21 14:15 發表
多數是選數學科的前60名或80名，要看看每班收學生多少，當然是成績好的學生選擇M1或M2先。

ANChan59

原帖由 snowbell 於 11-7-21 17:40 發表
如果剛巧自己讀那級勁人多，豈不爭M1,M2爭得你死我活, 合資格讀M1,M2有90人, 而得80個位, 最後那10人點算?  

I heard from a friend that his son is the 2nd batch of 334, and his school is a "B-1" school. also top 80 in Maths can take M1 or M2. At the end, close to half drop out from extended modules.

JP

原帖由 snowbell 於 11-7-21 10:20 發表
唔好放棄，試試同校方聯絡，可不可以在校讀M1.

一日未開學, 還有變數.

Sorry, 忘記了文憑試的科目, 除公開試的分數再加學校平時分, 所以無得自修.

看來比會考更無彈度. ...

For Maths and M1/M2 HKDSE, no School Base Assessment is required.

mio8390

依個世界一定有有幸有不幸，如果只能取得最低資格，入到可能未必一定好事，所以是讀不到是不幸還是幸運，要將來才知。
如果本身十分喜歡這科，也不應該取得這種分數，取得高分的同學一定比低分的更加喜歡，所以他們更加用功。

原帖由 snowbell 於 11-7-21 17:40 發表
如果剛巧自己讀那級勁人多，豈不爭M1,M2爭得你死我活, 合資格讀M1,M2有90人, 而得80個位, 最後那10人點算?  

cow

原帖由 gigivinda 於 11-7-21 13:52 發表
哎呀，真是忍不住要出句聲，不是大學收了就夠，要在大學讀得自在才成，也要大學畢業以后考專業試得心應手才成。沒有了calculus （M1/M2), Econ, Finance, Accounting, Physics, Insurance etc 都會讀得吃力。建議：不考試也要自修。

Agree if one's target subjects in U are Econ, Finance, Accounting, Physics, Engineering, and Insurance etc.

mio8390

我地以前讀書，大部份學生和文科生都沒有讀附加數，只有數學成績好的一班人可以修讀A math。

雙儿

原帖由 cow 於 11-7-22 10:06 發表

Agree if one's target subjects in U are Econ, Finance, Accounting, Physics, Engineering, and Insurance etc.

I'll revise the list to quantitative finance(not finance as in BBA), risk management, maths/physics-related science majors and engineering. Accounting does not need calculus at undergraduate level.

If your kid aims at quantitative finance or risk management, he is probably a top 2-3 percent student, we do not need to discuss further.

If he aims at maths/physics-related majors or engineering, he has to take M1/M2. If his grades are not good enough to take M1/M2, he can then only consider other majors. It does not mean the end of the world as currently no 恆商 students can read quantitative finance or risk management as they are not allowed to take pure mathematics at A level (this is probably one of the tactics used by the principal to avoid unnecessary competition with traditional elite schools).

For students aiming at other majors, why bother with M1/M2 which takes up much more time than other subjects and at the same time is not counted as a full subject. You are competing with better students as well.

One can always learn more maths after getting into university. And it is more relevant for PhD studies.

[ 本帖最後由 雙儿 於 11-7-22 14:37 編輯 ]

雙儿

原帖由 ha8mo 於 11-7-22 17:16 發表


即係話
改完學制都冇用
D學校自己冇進取心

其實自HKAL有左AS Maths and Stat後
已經多了Bio組或商組人有得在中六繼續讀數
現在反而倒退了

You can see it the other way. In the past, students could avoid maths totally after HKCEE. They did not have to be good in maths to be admitted to university. Now, maths is a compulsory subject through the end of F6 and you cannot choose to igore it if you want to have good grades for applying to university.

We are just switching from English-styled education to more American-styled education which emphasizes on one's overall ability.

[ 本帖最後由 雙儿 於 11-7-22 17:35 編輯 ]

雙儿

原帖由 ha8mo 於 11-7-22 22:32 發表
It is the same.

In both systems, a student must pass at least one Maths exam, a very easy exam.

It's not the same.

Students not good at maths in the past could manage a presentable "C" in maths in HKCEE and went on to concentrate on other subjects at A level. But now a less than good grade in maths will affect the chance of getting into university directly.

It is a common misconception to see maths as easy and additional maths as more difficult. Look at the % of getting grade A in maths and additional maths. Arguably, it is more difficult to get an A in maths than in additional maths. Questions in section B of the maths paper can be quite daunting and more difficult to prepare than A maths which contains questions usually repeated from past exams.

khmama524

雙儿 , please check pm.  Thanks!

cow

HKCEE A.Maths is definately more difficult than Maths.