用戶登入
用戶名稱：
密      碼：
登記帳號忘記密碼

討論區

教育王國
教育講場
使用意見
幼兒教育
幼校討論
幼教雜談
小學教育
小一選校
小學雜談
中學教育
升中派位
中學交流
初中教育
專上教育
備戰大學
選科選校
國際教育
國際學校
海外留學
知識增值
課外活動
教材閱讀
公開考試
深造進修
特殊教育
特殊教育
資優教育
自閉寶寶
智能評估
徵求專區
二手市場
誠徵老師
組班專區
徵保母車

   聯絡管理員
搜索
教育王國 › 討論區 › 國際學校 › 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校 ...
發新帖
查看: 5262|回覆: 15
 go

兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校 [複製鏈接]

foreverbb

Rank: 3Rank: 3


220
1#
發表於 07-6-28 18:11 |只看該作者

兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

有冇媽咪有此經驗?可否分享一下?

返回頂部

car-long

Rank: 3Rank: 3


268
2#
發表於 07-6-28 20:04 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

有咩問題 ?   我 d 仔女 ok wor!    local 果個味覺得自已咁多功課 , 另外果二個又咁得閑玩 ,  

返回頂部

babyoush

Rank: 3Rank: 3


337
3#
發表於 07-6-29 18:07 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

why you send one to local school but the other two to IS? I have 2 kids, I am thinking of sending them to IS but my husband always ask me why don't we send one to local and one to IS. To me I feel a little bit unfair but I also wonder maybe there will be good points for doing so?

返回頂部

nintendo

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


10361
4#
發表於 07-6-29 19:03 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

我親友中，有兩家人就係兩個小朋友，一個 local school，一個 IS 的。
一個家庭係重男輕女，家姐係讀免費的津貼學校，細老就由幼稚園已經係讀 IS，係要比 debenture 的。
另一個家庭，係父母覺得兩個小朋友性格唔同，細妹活動好動，家姐就文靜好多；佢地都有諗過比家姐一齊讀 IS，但父母怕佢太文靜，去到 IS 會更加 "唔起眼" ，做佈景板。
而家兩家庭的小朋友都係小學階段，暫時未有問題。

不過，未必個個人都識諗，未必個個人都唔小氣。
有 D 人小氣的，計較的，可能杯雪糕細杯 D 都嬲。
應該話，如果將來孩子長大時，真係唔介意，我覺得係你好采；如果佢將來介意，真係唔好覺得意外。

返回頂部

hjm

Rank: 3Rank: 3


425
5#
發表於 07-6-30 01:21 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

agreed, agreed....I am in such situation, well in fact, will be in this situation soon.  But what I'm thinking is more like your second case, trying to match the kid's character.  Afterall, sending both to IS will mean a lot of money (doubling at least) so we have to see (and save more money first!).  I don't know how this will be like for the future but will need to be watchful!

Any parents here who might be already experiencing this and may share views and challenges?

返回頂部

gwan

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1489
6#
發表於 07-6-30 09:45 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

I am also in this exact situation, my elder son is in IS and my younger son is with local school.

Honestly, if my elder son can be fitted in local school, I would prefer him to go there, not only we can save money, he can learn more Chinese too. But we know our elder son's character and ability well, he would have a super hard time if he is placed with a local school, on the other hand, I don't see my younger son have any problem. But we would put him to a  not so 'traditional' local school. Meaning those with less homework .

返回頂部

yeung2212

Rank: 4


815
7#
發表於 07-7-1 23:32 |只看該作者

Re: 兩個小朋友:一個讀傳統學校,一個讀國際學校

My family is also in such situation.

My elder son  is studying in Wah Yan Pimary school but my younger son in a international kindergarten. Of course I will put my younger son in international primary school also.

Why do I put them in this situation?
I am so disappointed to the traditional schools. Their cumriccums are so out and can't fit the current society. The teachers haven't teached so hard as they think the students can already learn the books from private tutor. My son's English is getting worse after studying in the traditional school. Therefore, I send my younger son to IS.

In fact, I also want to help my 1st son to IS. But, for financial problem, I can only afford one child.  I feel very sorrow to my 1st son.



返回頂部

44

Rank: 3Rank: 3


363
8#
發表於 07-7-3 22:29 |只看該作者
原文章由 nintendo 於 07-6-29 19:03 發表
不過，未必個個人都識諗，未必個個人都唔小氣。
有 D 人小氣的，計較的，可能杯雪糕細杯 D 都嬲。
應該話，如果將來孩子長大時，真係唔介意，我覺得係你好采；如果佢將來介意，真係唔好覺得意外。



that's true !!:
[url=www.babyhome.com.tw/JonathanPoon]J.Poon

返回頂部

hjm

Rank: 3Rank: 3


425
9#
發表於 07-7-4 01:22 |只看該作者
Wow, even Wah Yan is not good enough?  Well it's really hard...but I also met students from DGS, DBS primary who are extremely fluent with their spoken English, no HK accent at all.  Probably the families have put a lot of efforts into this too....

返回頂部

阿胡

Rank: 3Rank: 3


126
10#
發表於 07-7-11 10:17 |只看該作者
原文章由 hjm 於 07-7-4 01:22 發表
Wow, even Wah Yan is not good enough?  Well it's really hard...but I also met students from DGS, DBS primary who are extremely fluent with their spoken English, no HK accent at all.  Probably the ...



前日同一喇沙畢業生聊天, 了解到只有不多幾個最好的同學可以進入美國最好的幾間大學讀本科. 這同HKIS, CIS, ESF等相比差不少.

英文流利, 無香港口音當然很好, 但不管如何都是第二語言. 加上"本地名校"很多方面同國外大學不能銜接, 結果從讀好大學的百分比來看, 實在很不令人滿意.

國際學校, 本地名校, 各有所好, 各有所長.

但認為國際學校的校風不如本地學校, 實是以詐傳詐. 如果我們做父母的將此信以為真, 以此為不讀國際學校的主要原因, 結果可能誤了子女.

返回頂部

JennyL

Rank: 3Rank: 3


144
11#
發表於 07-7-11 11:51 |只看該作者
原文章由 阿胡 於 07-7-11 10:17 發表

英文流利, 無香港口音當然很好, 但不管如何都是第二語言.


I myself used to study in one of the "elite" girls' school. The so-called "very good English" in local elite schools is still not good enough. They are only "very good" when compared to other local school.

原文章由 阿胡 於 07-7-11 10:17 發表

但認為國際學校的校風不如本地學校, 實是以詐傳詐.



This "problem" is more than "rumours" --- just that some people are simply extremely hostile when talking about international school. The reasons of the hostility? I do not want to speculate.

返回頂部

阿胡

Rank: 3Rank: 3


126
12#
發表於 07-7-11 14:56 |只看該作者
說到校風問題, 好難以一概全.

不過, 國際學校提倡回饋社會. 我知道有的中學生每個星期去養老院給老人餵飯, 有一年時間. 這樣的中學生, 人品不會太差.

返回頂部

joyfung

Rank: 2


86
13#
發表於 07-7-13 10:52 |只看該作者
同意.
像我兒子的學校(kgv)和女兒的學校(cwbs)提倡環保, 他們便同心協力做好, 如慳電慳紙, 他們寧可熱些也少開冷氣, 會為世界著想, 相對local學生, 像我的學生(主要band2)和朋友的學生(主要band1), 因為交了冷氣費便一定要開, 怕蝕底, 就算不太熱的天氣, 穿著冷衫都要開, 老師經常教導, 都很難改變他們.

[ 本文章最後由 joyfung 於 07-7-13 10:56 編輯 ]

返回頂部

hjm

Rank: 3Rank: 3


425
14#
發表於 07-7-14 01:19 |只看該作者
" 國際學校提倡回饋社會" is something I agree with too.  To build a person's sense of belonging and responsibility nothing is better to make them do something!  Community and services are very emphasized within the IS environment.

返回頂部

CSW

Rank: 4


801
15#
發表於 07-7-28 00:33 |只看該作者
Glad to know that you have such a discussion here. I am thinking of sending my elder son, who will be promoting to P.2 in a local school, to an IS. I found the same situation as some of you had written here, e.g. the English conversation is going backwards; the learning ability is bounded by the ED curriculum. Even I know that the teachers are doing their very best to care and teach the students, I am worry that my son's talent cannot be fully developed under such education system.

But on the other hand, my younger son who is still in kindergarten now, has a totally different mode of learning. He can be very concentrate, and very self-displinary. That's why I think may be I can try some local schools like DBS, St. Paual Co. Ed, CKY, 國際音小...etc.
However, I am also concerning about the school fees for such arrangement.

I really want to hear more of your opinions. Thanks.

返回頂部

Yau_Cheung

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2258
16#
發表於 07-7-28 12:21 |只看該作者
I agree your opinion especially "未必個個人都識諗，未必個個人都唔小氣。
有 D 人小氣的，計較的，可能杯雪糕細杯 D 都嬲。
應該話，如果將來孩子長大時，真係唔介意，我覺得係你好采；如果佢將來介意，真係唔好覺得意外。"

On my case, I cannot afford 2 children study in IS but I know IS environment is better.  If I have 2 children, maybe 1 should join local.  So I decide to have 1 kid only.  Besides, I also ask my son's opinion and he always tell me that he don't want to have younger brother and sister.

For 2 children's case, if I cannot afford both in IS, I'll let both in local in order to avoid unfair.

返回頂部

‹ 上一主題|下一主題 ›
返回列表
發新帖