請教灣仔華仁小學

Ving

Hi,

I just wonder why Wah Yan is attractive, my point is

1. only half-day school
2. chinese primary and chinese secondary
3. not very outstanding external exam result, e.g HKCEE and HKALE

So, is it the strict discipline the only selling point to Wah Yan?

And is Wah Yan primary teach all subjects in chinese except english from P1-P5. Is there any comment? Thx

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-21 17:07 發表
視乎你想要乜野和想仔仔怎樣成長.
整体成績一定係St. Jo較好,但要付出代價.
華仁最強的不是成績,係德育. 一間冇記缺點冇記過,只記功記優點的學校.


...

Ving

But put in another way, is there any chinese primary that is better than wah yan,

or does it fair to compare wah yan with other english primary school as this is not apple to apple comparison...

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-22 11:07 發表
其實佢成績唔夠最Top個幾間好,唔代表佢唔好.只是學校冇比太大壓力d小朋友.
冇錯是一間中文小學,但英文水平都唔差.
除德育外,最大原因可能係開心成長及快樂童年.


...

Ving

Actually, as a parent, I think it is normal to focus on school conduct and result.

If only talking about good conduct, I think Wah Yan definitely not the only choice.

But in the discussion, people say that the academic of Wah Yan drops a lot compared with the past. Is there any real evidence for support or just a rumour.

Also, if some listed companies CEO are from Wah Yan and said that Wah Yan is good. I think this is not a strong reason to choose law. As there are many thousand listed compnies in Hong Kong and their CEO definitely not all from Wah Yan. I think they will also good mouth their mother school with few exceptions.

原帖由 Lilo 於 10-7-22 14:42 發表


其實中文小學有乜野問題呢?中文小學唔代表英文差.聖保羅男女小學李校長都成日強調佢地係中文小學.當然我明白英文小學對於某些家長來講係個迷思,我自己都有個住中西區親戚堅持聖嘉勒小學好過聖士提反女小,因為 ...

Ving

Actually, I would not argue that Wah Yan is not a good school.

But compared with its past, one of the best and top schools in HK island, does it step backwards a lot or not moving forward enough compared with other good govt/subsidy/private/DSS school.

I am for sure that there are still many followers to Wah Yan (especially the parents are graduates), but by considering the current situation, does it really worth chasing on it or put it no 1 in the selection list?

Is it also the same case happen in Kowloon Wah Yan as well? I am not sure and is there somebody can advise.

Just one side question, is there anyone know why Wah Yan keep on half-day school, is this due to resource problem or some other factors?

原帖由 traeh 於 10-7-22 16:42 發表

官方嘅中學概覽有寫：

(1)學校管理架構 :
採用平衡班級制，以英文為主要授課語言。在低年級(中一至中二)以混合學習形式，不設精英班制度。校本管理、校董會及校政諮詢委員會均有舊生及家長代表。

係香港華仁書院個we ...

Ving

Hi,

So, if the campus is not such big, will it affect the ECA? Is the school active in ECA or lessons only? thx

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 10:35 發表
香港和九龍各有一間華仁中學,小學得香港有,港華中會收番華小6-7成小朋友.

另因校園太小,課室只得12個,故只能每級2班,為教育更多的小朋友,故分成上下午.

...

Ving

So, does it mean that parents need to develope ECA for the boys themselves with extra resources rather than from the school?

If so, what the boy do in school after school, will it go back home straight? And how about the sense of belonging?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 11:38 發表
只得星期六長週才有課外活動或比錢出面個d.
真係好細但運動好勁,尤其足球,排球同游水.

Ving

So is this reasonable ECA facilities compared with other schools?

If most of the ECA is arranged from parents themselves, then this point should not be credit to the school, is it fair?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 12:40 發表
多數都出去攪. 放學後大部份人都係坐校車即走(偏辟),未走個d踼下波,打籃球或乒乓波等人接.
另童軍好出名.

Ving

Sorry, do you mean kicking football also need to pay for money?

Also, someone say that although only teach English in english lessons and other subjects in chinese. But english level in Wah Yan is good. Is it due to parents bring them to english tutor after schools or really very very good english teacher(foreigner english teacher??) at school. Can anyone suggest?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-23 15:53 發表
基本野佢都齊既,灣仔唔少學校都係咁細.
因學校都有介紹一d要比錢既課外活動,故好多時某些活動好多華仁仔,有d全部都係添(eg.踼波).

Ving

Is there anyone know the ECA facilities of Wah Yan against St Joseph against Henessy Gov? Which one is better and which one is the worst.

原帖由 珀珀,慧慧媽 於 10-7-25 13:18 發表

唔好意思~~
想問下學校細咁小朋友在小息時咪冇咩活動空間走動LOR~~
小朋友在小息時通常有咩可以做呢??
另外比錢既課外活動係咪會在星期六放學後進行??是否全都要家長自行接送呢?? ...

Ving

If it does not go to tutor either am or pm, then do you think the academic is good or bad than those full day school. I  just wonder the boys will play game or watch TV either am or pm in the weekdays

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 15:44 發表
1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.

Ving

Also, I just wonder how traditional schools like Wah Yan can get the best student to study.

1. No interview required
2. No language or aptitude required. Means if you have enough marks, then even you peform far worse than other students, you get a place
3. The entry marks is only depending on parents/brother graduation status and religion. However these two are nothing related with the student potential

So, that's I wonder how they maintain the level of P1 students?

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-27 15:44 發表
1. 20分有機會,但只可揀其中一晝.
2. 成績好好,唔會最top,但一定係好好.
3. band 1尾個d中學
4. 大多數不會,平民較多.