請教灣仔華仁小學

babych

請教各位高人, 現在華仁小學好嗎?  可否幚忙分析下這所小學好與壞? 謝謝大家 !

ukodelechan

好似香港華仁好過九龍華仁好多

TinHay

香港華仁vs St. Joe?

原帖由 ukodelechan 於 10-7-20 20:23 發表
好似香港華仁好過九龍華仁好多

brian61950

單論成績,St. Joseph is better.

原帖由 TinHay 於 10-7-21 14:53 發表
香港華仁vs St. Joe?

babych

我見到有些討論都說現在華仁小學/中學明顯比以前退步了很多, 我唸, 爛船都有三分釘, 因為有聯係中學關係, 若果成績 keep 到, 都仍然很吸引?  如果係你小朋友入到, 你地會唔會選華小呢? 謝謝!

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-21 15:10 發表
單論成績,St. Joseph is better.

brian61950

螺飯應,
香港區津校來講我個人認為整體最好.

原帖由 babych 於 10-7-21 15:45 發表
我見到有些討論都說現在華仁小學/中學明顯比以前退步了很多, 我唸, 爛船都有三分釘, 因為有聯係中學關係, 若果成績 keep 到, 都仍然很吸引?  如果係你小朋友入到, 你地會唔會選華小呢? 謝謝!

...

lamlauanita

What about Wah Yan vs Hennessy Gov Primary School (A.M)?

brian61950

如肯定仔仔到五六年級時都一定係考頭幾名,那軒小好d,因可入皇仁.
如不肯定,華仁好好多.

原帖由 lamlauanita 於 10-7-21 16:50 發表
What about Wah Yan vs Hennessy Gov Primary School (A.M)?

TinHay

From what I've read, I will take Hennessy PM because there is 精英班 ＆ 普教中班.  In addition, for us working mom, staying up late is okay la.  We can still check homework.

原帖由 lamlauanita 於 10-7-21 16:50 發表
What about Wah Yan vs Hennessy Gov Primary School (A.M)?

TinHay

What about over all performance after 6 years of primary???

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-21 15:10 發表
單論成績,St. Joseph is better.

lamlauanita

Dear brian61950

Thanks for your comment.

brian61950

視乎你想要乜野和想仔仔怎樣成長.
整体成績一定係St. Jo較好,但要付出代價.
華仁最強的不是成績,係德育. 一間冇記缺點冇記過,只記功記優點的學校.

原帖由 TinHay 於 10-7-21 17:00 發表
What about over all performance after 6 years of primary???

Ving

Hi,

I just wonder why Wah Yan is attractive, my point is

1. only half-day school
2. chinese primary and chinese secondary
3. not very outstanding external exam result, e.g HKCEE and HKALE

So, is it the strict discipline the only selling point to Wah Yan?

And is Wah Yan primary teach all subjects in chinese except english from P1-P5. Is there any comment? Thx

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-21 17:07 發表
視乎你想要乜野和想仔仔怎樣成長.
整体成績一定係St. Jo較好,但要付出代價.
華仁最強的不是成績,係德育. 一間冇記缺點冇記過,只記功記優點的學校.


...

Sumyeema1

i like this..but my son only got 10 points.

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-21 17:07 發表

華仁最強係德育. 一間冇記缺點冇記過,只記功記優點的學校.


...

babych

我一直心目中既華仁小學係一間德育/成績都非常好既學校,由囝囝出生以來, 此小學是我們之一目標. 到了囝囝p1,呢幾年我都好留意bk各位mani既留言,我發覺大家對華仁小學既看法好像變了,本來堅定既我對此校越來越迷糊, 大家都說這所傳統學校成績差了,有更多更好既學校, 而好多其它新興(直資/津校)學校非常之受家長歡迎.這所小學好像前年轉了新校長, 由新校長帶領下, 前景會唔會變好?

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 10-7-22 10:42 發表
i like this..but my son only got 10 points.

[ 本帖最後由 babych 於 10-7-22 11:02 編輯 ]

brian61950

其實佢成績唔夠最Top個幾間好,唔代表佢唔好.只是學校冇比太大壓力d小朋友.
冇錯是一間中文小學,但英文水平都唔差.
除德育外,最大原因可能係開心成長及快樂童年.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-22 08:16 發表
Hi,

I just wonder why Wah Yan is attractive, my point is

1. only half-day school
2. chinese primary and chinese secondary
3. not very outstanding external exam result, e.g HKCEE and HKALE

So, is it ...

TinHay

same here.  
There is only one chance, only one target primary school which hopefully will lead to a good 德育secondary school and no school fee.  

Besides the government & aided schools, there are still the following private & DSS for boys in HK Island that is under consideration:
Private
聖士提反較輕鬆,會寄宿,競爭都唔細
高主教成績唔錯,中學都唔差,競爭大.
DSS
聖保羅男校成績方面較好,競爭好大.

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 10-7-22 10:42 發表
i like this..but my son only got 10 points.

[ 本帖最後由 TinHay 於 10-7-27 18:10 編輯 ]

Ving

But put in another way, is there any chinese primary that is better than wah yan,

or does it fair to compare wah yan with other english primary school as this is not apple to apple comparison...

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-7-22 11:07 發表
其實佢成績唔夠最Top個幾間好,唔代表佢唔好.只是學校冇比太大壓力d小朋友.
冇錯是一間中文小學,但英文水平都唔差.
除德育外,最大原因可能係開心成長及快樂童年.


...

brian61950

中文小學好過佢既有喇沙.

冇乜fair唔fair,佢都好過唔少英文小學.
如想求成績或做狀元既,華仁唔係幾適合.
香港區津校來講,佢仍是好多人的首選.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-7-22 12:26 發表
But put in another way, is there any chinese primary that is better than wah yan,

or does it fair to compare wah yan with other english primary school as this is not apple to apple comparison...



...