北大朗誦比賽是否值得參加?

circle123

想問有無媽咪知道北大朗誦比賽是否有水準和有認受性,因一月好似有比賽,想給囡囡參加,請給些意見和資料,是否在這裡www.pkuschool.hk報名穩陣些,因他們話自己是直接和北大協辦的.唔知是否似校際般咁認真(評判)!

charlottechan

我女兒參加北大舉辦的運動會, 原定3pm結束, 結果5pm都未完. 6-7人manage幾百人的運動會,$250一個項目,一面比賽一面收錢讓人插隊參加. must add in your blacklist

真真

上星期收倒宣傳單張, 差d上當, 多謝大家的發表.
今次佢地改咗名叫做
"亞太兒童朗誦節"

!貓貓老婆!

睇完壹週刊，真係搵笨喎...我都唔會幫個女報。

maglam1985

原帖由 kenchu 於 09-6-22 11:42 發表
值得參加啦..

我係路過, 我見人人話揾笨, 但你就話值得參加,
你係咪參加過呢?有乜值得參加之處?
請憑良心說?

Ansonrubby

好同意呀！我當年仲報埋佢地的課程，閒日上午的人少(3-4人)，情況OK，但有次去上週末的課簡直離譜，竟成十個小朋友，最多咪練到一次！裡面好嘈架：有不同年紀的小朋友在談笑或哭鬧，完成冇秩序，點練？

綵排、比賽亦然！有人唔想等綵排的，可以同黃xx講2句就去後台練。我走時在counter見到有孩子受傷了。
比賽仲騎尼！居然有媽咪抱埋bb入去，仲不時喊tim, 冇人請佢出去bor. 即是要參賽小朋友在哭喊聲中朗誦！ 大會同個媽咪都好尊重參賽者 ！

原帖由 Louisa 於 09-6-22 19:51 發表
呢間智X (Learning KXX) 好搵笨, 大家千祈唔好報任何"北大"既比賽同course呀 .  我都曾經係受害者之一

[ 本帖最後由 Ansonrubby 於 09-6-23 08:28 編輯 ]

cemily

My child had prizes in most of his speech competitions but never had anything in 北大 competitions.

But that did not stop me from entering cos my main aim was for him to stand in front of an audience and just speak. It's this experience that I paid for. 北大 served this purpose as they had competitions once every few months.

Other competitions like 普師 are v good because well organised, fair, quality judges and quality participants. My child learned a lot from it and happy to get a prize. But it's only once a year. We needed more practice.

e

beckylui

Double losses - wasting time; wasting money!!!

Louisa

呢間智X (Learning KXX) 好搵笨, 大家千祈唔好報任何"北大"既比賽同course呀 .  我都曾經係受害者之一

原帖由 竹葉青 於 09-6-22 12:59 發表
壹x刊(封面講學童索k果期),內有講e間野揾笨喎!

竹葉青

壹x刊(封面講學童索k果期),內有講e間野揾笨喎!

原帖由 kenchu 於 09-6-22 11:42 發表
值得參加啦..

Bee_168

9月校際朗誦比賽開始報名了，明年1月有個金紫荊朗誦大賽，明年3月普師會又有比賽，大家努力啦，有冇獎都好，我覺得個女上台叻著好多﹗

Bee_168

我講番我既case，我同個女去北大比賽，個日佢讀得好好，以為有獎啦，點知冇，唯有單單地走人，點知係架lift遇到個比賽評判，佢一見到我個女就話恭喜我話我個女好叻，搞到我地一頭霧水，我同佢講我個女冇獎，佢好奇怪，我同佢返轉頭去搵北大d工作人員，佢地走鬼晒，你地話呢個乜鬼比賽呀........黑暗，搞乜鬼???? ...心知啦...

凱富路

一周刊今期報導﹕

新聞耳目 - 借北大之名搵家長老襯

小一派位剛放榜，不少家長見子女獲派心儀小學，開心到好似中六合彩。這世代家長將子女當成金叵羅，願意大灑金錢為子女鋪路，難怪近年專辦小朋友增值活動的機構愈開愈多。
坊間一間標榜與北京大學附中附小遠程教育.......

原帖由 circle123 於 08-12-3 03:21 發表
想問有無媽咪知道北大朗誦比賽是否有水準和有認受性,因一月好似有比賽,想給囡囡參加,請給些意見和資料,是否在這裡www.pkuschool.hk報名穩陣些,因他們話自己是直接和北大協辦的.唔知是否似校際般咁認真(評判)! ...

ALAL

My nephew just joined the competition, in spite of my objection.  Her experience is very bad.

AM

呢度好多媽咪都講過『北大朗誦節』質素好差 ,
希望唔好再有BK媽咪上當

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?action=printable&tid=1301382

原帖由 ysmhkg 於 08-12-4 22:28 發表
這是今年年初我們參加比賽後心得:

一個不專業的機構 + 一堆不合格的評審 +  一個不成熟的大會主持人+ 一個亂七八糟的頒獎典禮 = 一個不堪回首但又記憶深刻的回憶

不要被 " 北大 "二字給欺騙了.

...

kakaloklok

好彩有你們咋...
原來又係擝人笨...
:;pppp:
討 厭

bbsunny88

綜合晒咁多位媽咪意見,全部均屬實.
今年,我都有幫小兒報名,這間不知所謂的機構及主持人"黃先生", 全部$$$字當頭, 明明第二及三名跟本朗誦得不好,都可以得獎, 擺明搵笨,重收$250報名費,最唔明點解遲到重可以有機會出場,咁要時間黎重咩, 對準時的人根本唔公平. 亂七八遭, 最後取分紙係自己在出面張書檯度摷的,唔係由職員派,唔怪得維多利亞小學要杯葛佢地,唔讚成學生參加啦.
我話過,唔會"side"錢參加呢間不知所謂既朗誦比賽. 免得side 錢& side 時間.

tmf

one parent told me that she let her son join the P1 interview course in this center, but she quit after a few lesson because she said that she didn't know what they did. Just waste her money and time of kids.