第二屆全港學生公開音樂比賽

video_ming

這是一個十分殘酷的比賽.我都很傷心. 一個付出過努力的小朋友,換來這樣的評語.作為家長十分傷心. . 好像你努力做了些事,給你的老板時,老板一把打過來,說垃圾的感覺.

原帖由 yvonne.wong 於 09-10-17 01:08 發表
這是一個十分十分不公平的比賽

[ 本帖最後由 video_ming 於 09-10-18 22:23 編輯 ]

chanel2009

Can I ask you both why do you say this is so? It is with experience, and my friend's experience that this competition is encouraging, and because it is small groups, children get to learn more from their comments?

Why is it unfair? Is it because your child didn't win ? Competition is competition, it's all about the adjudicator's opinion. Unless there are more than 1 adjudicators. I think examinations are sometimes very unfair. I think HKSMA's competitions are very very unfair too !

video_ming

我是10月15日的比賽.我小朋友每天練琴1個多小時,假日是2~3小時,跟的老師都是有小小明的音樂家.得的結果是這樣

原帖由 yvonne.wong 於 09-10-17 21:35 發表
不但小朋友努力, 家長和老師都付出了很多, 又要比500幾元, 又要給評判愚弄, 又要造馬, 又要浪費家長的時間.請問您是不是參加了10月14日嗰場比賽

chanel2009

interesting.... it must be disappointing, but "performance" is performance. Just because your child practices alot, or sits at the piano alot doesn't mean he or she is guaranteed to win right?

video_ming

在這個比賽裡.我看不見鼓勵.
評語上一點鼓勵字都沒有.
我當初參加時的心,都是想在此裡給予一些鼓勵比囡囡.我沒有想要拿什麼獎.

原帖由 chanel2009 於 09-10-17 22:09 發表
Can I ask you both why do you say this is so? It is with experience, and my friend's experience that this competition is encouraging, and because it is small groups, children get to learn more from th ...

chanel2009

Really? You mean the comments are all negative? No encouraging remarks?
If so, it is definitely the adjudicator, but not the competiton's tone of voice.

I participated in their speech competition (well my kids) twice , last year and this year, I find they maintained "competitive" atmosphere, but with encouragment to children by giving each a medalion, trophies for winners, and comments that indicate good and bad things about my kids' performance.

Why the music one is not, then it must be the adjudicator? There was a session on Friday, Oct 16, different adjudicator. Maybe different?

A1

....................

[ 本帖最後由 A1 於 09-12-13 23:32 編輯 ]

chanel2009

I know who the adjudictor is now... a friend 's child played on Oct 14, and according to them, the adjudicator is same as Oct 15.... this adjudicator is very qualified, and wrote a book about how to be a better piano teacher.

She said everyone enjoyed his adjudication, many laughed, and learned a lot.

chanel2009

wootaitai,

Are you sure we are talking about the same competition? The speech one this year was held at Sheung Wan Civic Center, and each child was sitting with a parent, and very on time, and there was no waiting room.

Speech mark sheet- I agree, no written comments, just check marks on a chart.

chanel2009

Oh really? That is pretty bad.

Well, this competition is still only in its 2nd year, I think it's only fair to give it some time, I think they are trying to improve the best they can.
I see they were more organized than last year already, they learned, and they tried to fix it.

It's not easy to satisfy thousands of parents, teachers, and students, and have to make everyone happy.