聖士提反 (Stanley)

weiweiwei

Dear All Parents,

We had attended the briefing of 聖士提反 (Stanley).... and the principal never mention they won this year 第60屆香港學校音樂節.... (comparing with SPCC briefing, video looping again & again)

Just for sharing, 聖士提反 (Stanley) had won the contest :第60屆香港學校音樂節優勝者表演小學十歲及以下中文合唱隊 .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_lm0fwirdM&feature=related

You may have better reference for 聖士提反 (Stanley) kids for making decision.

Enjoy!

waiwaibaba

原帖由 weiweiwei 於 09-11-19 14:52 發表
Dear All Parents,

We had attended the briefing of 聖士提反 (Stanley).... and the principal never mention they won this year 第60屆香港學校音樂節.... (comparing with SPCC briefing, video looping again ...

BTW can U elaborate yr observation as to diff between students of ST Stephen and of SPCC at the performance?

weiweiwei

just for sharing... here is the kids perforemance from SPCC:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2crOuGdx9wI&feature=related

1. SPCC has much higher technique, present precisely and accurately. The kids are full of confidence.. Every key,
every tone are perfectly presented. No mistake, finishing the song to get the highest marks.

2. Singing is from heart... when u listen St. Stephen... the soul and passionate are in overall dominance.... And somehow you will feel touching melody in the song.

3. That is somehow like benchmark in 超級巨聲 .... SPCC is fine in presentation and eager to win ! St. Stephen is perform what they are really like to present from the heart and give a nice song to the audience.. You may feel that.

Just personal comments, thx for all!

waiwaibaba

原帖由 weiweiwei 於 09-11-19 15:09 發表
just for sharing... here is the kids perforemance from SPCC:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2crOuGdx9wI&feature=related

1. SPCC has much higher technique, present precisely and accurately. The kids  ...

Great observation! I think it also reflect the difference  in school's objectives.

1 care more for the school reputation and ranking; 1 care more for their students' all-round development

Poto123

grDaddy

I thought weiweiwei is too subjective to say so.

However, I agree with weiweiwei after watching their performances.

Did just the melody make people feeling differently?

ssspwong

The following is the performance of SSCPS. They won in the Chinese Choral Speaking and then was invited to perform during 神七訪港

聖士提反書院附屬小學朗誦表演  

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkKrDhOLNf0

Enjoy it!

[ 本帖最後由 ssspwong 於 09-11-21 16:31 編輯 ]

childrenfirst

thanks for the postings! I really enjoy the song of the kids from St stephens. I think the song itself is very meaningful.

weiweiwei

And, u may find the St. Stephen kids are really enjoying the song and singing rather than fight for the wins... May be we are too subjective... but that is what we are hearing... thx. for all sharing !

good-boy

Oh, I like this post.

Thank you very much for your sharing.