GH vs SFA

PW530

GH
冇校巴、學費貴啲，有中學

SFA
有校巴、學費平啲，冇中學

pls comment !!!!

HelenHillary

你住得邊間近D呢？但遠近可以搬嘅.....都十五十六。
學術方面唔知分別。有人話SFA＂都好谷下＂ GH" 都唔差。
升中方面 Sfa通常女入上智女校？GH
有中學back up 但不是100%保證。
仲有口羊考慮呢？請高人補充下。

PW530

真係十五十六 SFA 近屋企啲(45分鐘)......

兩間成績都好，但SFA 應該嚴啲，我大嫂個女讀緊小五，大嫂覺得女仔唔啱讀，中學網唔好又辛苦，但我眼見佢個女又ok woo....我會再和大嫂研究吓

GH 啲學生好乖，應該都開心嘅，但要由屋企坐村巴出荃灣再坐校車返學(一小時多啲)，仲要返好早(7:30am)


比啲意見

brian61950

有人話SFA 可能係全港課程最深的小學,捱得過既,校網點差都冇問題啦!
成績好咪得囉.

csbaik

GH
雖然學費貴啲但有中學back-up, 升到小六唔洗憂派得唔好.就算差都會派英中!

SFA
有校巴、學費平啲，但冇中學，深水埗個綱麻麻地，如果個得差分分中入左中中。每年的小六生都會考gh,當正佢係宝。既然两間standard 一樣,點解誤一早同個女輔路!

PW530

Thank you for your comment !!!! ^^

原帖由 csbaik 於 10-11-28 22:57 發表
GH
雖然學費貴啲但有中學back-up, 升到小六唔洗憂派得唔好.就算差都會派英中!

SFA
有校巴、學費平啲，但冇中學，深水埗個綱麻麻地，如果個得差分分中入左中中。每年的小六生都會考gh,當正佢係宝。既然两間standard 一樣, ...

survivor

I have no doubt that both are good schools. The only difference is if you want to go through another year of stress. I know some parents with kids studying in SFA. They worry and worry for six full years for Form 1 admission challenge. It does not mean your kid is not good enough to stand the test. I personally don't agree with this kind of education system, in which your kid needs to work hard and join many competitions to win to prove his/her ability. It is definitely not healthy for kids.

One more point! If you perform good in GH, you can move to another school easily. But it is less easy in SFA.

小曳人

我會考慮埋會唔會搬, 唔搬嘅就唔好諗GH
會考慮搬先再講邊間啱d~

joeyma

因為我又係要晨咁早起身返工既人，我知果種滋味。
我覺得要個細佬女咁早起身，好可憐！唔好忘記佢夜晚仲要做功課及溫書至好夜。

Chumeiying

The school distance from home is a critical consideration.  Don't forget you have to take the school bus before 6:30am for school starts at 7:40am.  You may check the complaints of other mums about the prolonged school bus service at GH.  A big problem, your daughter will suffer a lot.  Think about it!

fungwongphie

Let me tell you......my colleague's daughter needs to get up at 5:30am to catch the school bus arriving at around 6am to go to GH from Tsing Yi!!!!!!! We 炳炳 him for quite a year......he now 死死氣 drives her to school everyday.....that's already Tsing Yi......seems you're living quite apart from Tsing Yi too 噃.....

Jackie310

The class size of GH is big (45 students in a class) and the school fees are expensive, especially the upper level of secondary school. I heard a friend's daughter changed to 恆商 in F.6.

HappyJolly

原帖由 survivor 於 10-11-29 09:17 發表
I have no doubt that both are good schools. The only difference is if you want to go through another year of stress. I know some parents with kids studying in SFA. They worry and worry for six full ye ...

"...One more point! If you perform good in GH, you can move to another school easily. But it is less easy in SFA...."
Any real case for sharing?

PW530

多謝各位意見
總之有好、有5好....