民生 vs 根德園

Ricolas

民生 vs 根德園 ...which one u will pick?

e33895

民生.. 因為一條龍

拾仔

真係咁多人like一條龍?why?

dlmcdlcl

我都想問呢個問題.....

其實我再諗遠小小, 大家一起討論一下點揀.

KV, 雖然係教學理念, 教學課程都好合適"咸"接小一, 但係, 都要睇個小朋友有幾多斤兩, 如果佢唔夠SMART, 到將來考小一, 都唔會太標青. 可能考好多間才有1間半間OFFER.....但如果住既地區校網好, 亦有得駁一駁抽獎.

民生, 係可以直上小一 (不是太差的話) 但小一的質素, 好似唔值 $3,XXX 蚊學費, 佢又冇得玩 LUCKY DRAW, 所以一定係硬食讀私小OR DSS, 讀得民生都係鍾意佢一條龍唔洗煩小一, 但去到小一又可能會報下 DSS / PRIVATE SCHOOL, 咁又好似攞O黎攪, 但乜都唔報, 又覺得佢小一真係一般般. 中學更加話越來越差.

好煩!!!

其實我仲有培道 PM OFFER, 我個係女, 有個哥哥今年考小一, 佢都係讀KV的, 成績真係唔錯, 又有CERT, 但今年戰績都係一般, 有間私小OFFER, 係男校, 所以到妹妹, 我真係心大心細究竟點揀.

牌面, 好似培道都唔錯, 小一平平地, 校風低調, 到中學就係津貼女校 (中中).

我仲會IN 埋宣道. 睇O黎都要交千幾2千蚊留位費拖住先.

大家傾下啦....

拾仔

我又幾同意你的講法,kv我無報我有報民生&培正仲有創價所以我都有同你一樣感覺........如果創價收都唔知點因為我like佢,不過講到其他兩間都收佢地又係一條龍唉~~~我都真係幾煩,而民小$3xxx又真係唔值,個日in完培正d老師又黑口黑面我又有dd唔想讀佢.........你話點好?而家都係等~~~

原帖由 dlmcdlcl 於 10-11-30 22:20 發表
我都想問呢個問題.....

其實我再諗遠小小, 大家一起討論一下點揀.

KV, 雖然係教學理念, 教學課程都好合適"咸"接小一, 但係, 都要睇個小朋友有幾多斤兩, 如果佢唔夠SMART, 到將來考小一, 都唔會太標青. 可能考好多 ...

97015018

我小朋友在民生讀K1-K3，今年上了一年級，但我不揀在民生讀一年級。
因為我覺民生太傳統，包括由幼稚園起都是，所以如果真是考慮好小朋友是適合這間學校才這樣揀，否則不要太早為小朋友決定一條龍，當初我都是想著一條龍所以揀佢，放放棄了很多選擇，但讀讀吓發現都唔係太適合我小朋友，所以K3民生雖然都有收佢讀小學，但最後我都決定轉校。
但講真，民生除了好似有些小學保障和校園夠大外，其他都是一般。

原帖由 拾仔 於 10-11-30 22:30 發表
我又幾同意你的講法,kv我無報我有報民生&培正仲有創價所以我都有同你一樣感覺........如果創價收都唔知點因為我like佢,不過講到其他兩間都收佢地又係一條龍唉~~~我都真係幾煩,而民小$3xxx又真係唔值,個日in完培正d老 ...

dlmcdlcl

創價, 都好好, 考小一應該唔會太輸蝕, 只係都要好好培育小朋友, 出去學野冇走雞!!

培正, 我當自己落左選的了, 因為佢好大機會係收父母高學歷或專業人士. 所以我一定冇行. 但如果培正真係爆冷, 我一定會揀佢.

kitty_tang

原帖由 拾仔 於 10-11-30 22:30 發表
我又幾同意你的講法,kv我無報我有報民生&培正仲有創價所以我都有同你一樣感覺........如果創價收都唔知點因為我like佢,不過講到其他兩間都收佢地又係一條龍唉~~~我都真係幾煩,而民小$3xxx又真係唔值,個日in完培正d老 ...

我想問如果讀民生幼稚園,到小學可以唔讀民生.因為我個囡都有報創價.(個人覺得校舍唔係好大,室外活動空間好似唔夠.但口碑又好喎) 要IN 完民生先有得比較. 你個小朋友IN 左民生未?

dlmcdlcl

可以講你小朋友現在讀那間嗎?
你是否留左位民生, 再考DSS/ PRIVATE SCHOOL 定點??
唔好意思, 你既意見真係好有用.
反而我最大既CONCERN 係 $3,XXX 如果考到KTS, APS的話, 我都唔會讀民生, 咁我當初讀左民幼又好似挷死自己咁囉.....但又可以咁諗, 真係咁黑, 考唔到小一都仲有民小做BACKUP. 所以先煩.

原帖由 97015018 於 30-11-2010 10:36 PM 發表
我小朋友在民生讀K1-K3，今年上了一年級，但我不揀在民生讀一年級。
因為我覺民生太傳統，包括由幼稚園起都是，所以如果真是考慮好小朋友是適合這間學校才這樣揀，否則不要太早為小朋友決定一條龍，當初我都是想著一條龍所以揀佢 ...

拾仔

創價個個都話好(個人睇法靚d亞女好like)民生好舊,民生我in左啦,你未in無理由架唔係in哂???

原帖由 kitty_tang 於 10-11-30 22:37 發表

我想問如果讀民生幼稚園,到小學可以唔讀民生.因為我個囡都有報創價.(個人覺得校舍唔係好大,室外活動空間好似唔夠.但口碑又好喎) 要IN 完民生先有得比較. 你個小朋友IN 左民生未? ...

dlmcdlcl

民生, 我又唔覺舊喎, 都好企理, D 課室都大. 空間都多.
可能我仔讀KV, KV 都仲舊.仲傳統.

我仲有禮賢會IN, 但禮賢幼稚園都好多PROJECT做, 我覺得冇用. 我FRIEND 個仔讀完, 上小一很辛苦. 但禮賢都有小一, 不過, 小一都要 IN, 基本上唔太差都會收.
我都 LIKE 宣道, 我都會IN, 宣道都係好, 又平又有小一, 雖然都係收返60個幼稚園生. 都有機. 但宣小就好谷.

原帖由 拾仔 於 30-11-2010 10:43 PM 發表
創價個個都話好(個人睇法靚d亞女好like)民生好舊,民生我in左啦,你未in無理由架唔係in哂???

拾仔

原來係咁......kv仲舊?我唔知呀因為我怕佢太谷我無報呀,民生係呀我覺得舊姐,不過培正仲舊(都係個人意見) 宣道本黎諗住報到最後無....即係你仲未in哂........唉我in哂lu而家只好等

原帖由 dlmcdlcl 於 10-11-30 22:48 發表
民生, 我又唔覺舊喎, 都好企理, D 課室都大. 空間都多.
可能我仔讀KV, KV 都仲舊.仲傳統.

我仲有禮賢會IN, 但禮賢幼稚園都好多PROJECT做, 我覺得冇用. 我FRIEND 個仔讀完, 上小一很辛苦. 但禮賢都有小一, 不過, 小 ...

dlmcdlcl

我仲差禮賢 & 宣幼未 IN

原帖由 拾仔 於 30-11-2010 10:55 PM 發表
原來係咁......kv仲舊?我唔知呀因為我怕佢太谷我無報呀,民生係呀我覺得舊姐,不過培正仲舊(都係個人意見) 宣道本黎諗住報到最後無....即係你仲未in哂........唉我in哂lu而家只好等




...

kitty_tang

原帖由 拾仔 於 10-11-30 22:43 發表
創價個個都話好(個人睇法靚d亞女好like)民生好舊,民生我in左啦,你未in無理由架唔係in哂???

今個星期六先IN. 我都冇諗過讀民生小學.到時諗住大抽獎. 因為$3XXX多學費太貴啦.

路人甲2012

咁你仔仔最後選了那間小學 ?

原帖由 97015018 於 10-11-30 22:36 發表
我小朋友在民生讀K1-K3，今年上了一年級，但我不揀在民生讀一年級。
因為我覺民生太傳統，包括由幼稚園起都是，所以如果真是考慮好小朋友是適合這間學校才這樣揀，否則不要太早為小朋友決定一條龍，當初我都是想著一條龍所以揀佢 ...

Ricolas

Luckily, my gal was picked by KV but only PM class, I did not expect she was chosen, since she is small gal and did not perform very well during interview.
Anyway, we also went for MS interview last wk, teachers were much nicer and we both (me and her dad) liked the school's environment pretty much.

By comparing the cost:

KV - $2400 / mth
MS - $600 / mth

KV primary - $3000 / mth
MS - if go for primary - $0 / mth

Actually MS primary is not too expensive if we saved the money fm KV...

But, here is the point, if MS is good as the comments we've read online?

And, as I've read from dlmcdlcl, her boy also had good offer from other private school as her boy was performing good in KV.


Since I m not living in KT area, so, my gal may ended with "numbers picking" ????


If my gal was studied in MS, and not going to MS primary, does she has a better chance than KV to go for a better private primary school in KT?


It's just too complicated.........

vic6

我囡個FD都係無在MS小讀, 自己出去叩門入了Kowloon Tong 津貼女校, 因佢媽媽話MS小可以每年加學費, 日後唔知會否加到好似GH咁貴. 但佢都同我推介MS幼稚園老師教得好好,好nice,有NET + 普通話老師.所以佢叫我一定要in 埋.
我仲有2間未in, MS是其中一間.

原帖由 路人甲2012 於 10-12-1 00:00 發表
咁你仔仔最後選了那間小學 ?

kellyjason

Hi dlmcdlcl
My daughter (Jan-05) is studying in KV K3 also and her academic reports are also very good since K1.  She also studies a lot of extra-curriculum activities, got some cert such as Starters and even got some awards in verse speaking open competition.  All her teachers commented she is very smart and quite matured than other students.
However, the result of P1 admission is not good as expected, only 1 offer on hand now (not top rank school), no offers by SFA and GH that we was quite confidient in the original.  Need to wait for the results of the remaining schools.  (we applied MaryKnoll in Govt 1st round 派位 as we thought my daughter should got offers from most of the schools)
We really don't know what happened to my daughter ?  We now think that even how smart you think your kids are or study in KV, the results may not as expected as there are too many other factors would affect the interview results.  So, we plan to get a offer first for my younger daughter (K1 in KV now) from the school that my wife gradurated in the Govt 1st round "派位" as a backup, then try to apply other private/DSS schools.  

原帖由 dlmcdlcl 於 10-11-30 22:20 發表
我都想問呢個問題.....

其實我再諗遠小小, 大家一起討論一下點揀.

KV, 雖然係教學理念, 教學課程都好合適"咸"接小一, 但係, 都要睇個小朋友有幾多斤兩, 如果佢唔夠SMART, 到將來考小一, 都唔會太標青. 可能考好多 ...

Winnietao

民生啦,一條龍唔洗煩,亦可以考其他私校/dss,再可以大抽獎

viandes

去咗咁多間學校, 環境最好係民生, 雖然佢教學係傳统D, 但近年轉咗校長, 已漸漸加入新嘅教學方式, 接近傳统+活動教學, 我都幾鐘意。而根德園, 我覺得唔似幼稚園, 可能入去讀真係齋讀書, 好谷, in完感覺麻麻哋, c6同我都話唔會俾個仔入去讀咯!!