Yip's Choir or School Choir??

hoihoima

My boy is currently in Yip's Choir.  He really likes singing.  I am not keen on letting him attending both the Yip's choir and school choir since that would be too much practice and too much burden on his voice.  He also has a very busy schedule and cannot afford joining two choir.  I am thinking which one he should choose.

Based on my observation, Yip's choir is more professional and should be able to provide a better training than the school choir.  If he stays with Yip's, he may be able to go to singing tour abroad when he grows up.  There also seems to be more chances for performance.  Yip's choir has both boys and girls.  The good thing is that the sound of the choir is very rich (i.e. contains the voice of both boys and girls).  However, the down side is that boys would not have as much chance as girls in a choir.  Boys would always be the "green leaves".

On the other hand, joining the school choir would mean that he can participate in the choir competition with his schoolmates.  He is in a boy school, so he will not be outweighted by girl (like in Yip's).  

How would you choose?  Staying with Yip's choir or joining the school choir instead?

bebebe12345

孩子多大了、準備轉聲未,如果真的喜歡Vocal.....不要太心急、唱壞了不能再回頭。讓他參加學校的Choir足矣,當然要學校有放一點心機。轉聲前至後都要好好保養,男校並無不妥。

queenmiffy

其實你有答案~yip's

miss321

視乎那間學校，如學校training 好，又重視choir, 我覺得學校好啲。

lillymarie

如果學校重視合唱團，我都覺得參加學校的好些，一來在學校參加活動，尤其是合唱團，成績表會有紀錄。二來時間上省下很多不必要的往來。最後是和同學們一起練唱，可以識到學校裏的朋友。

樓主提及葉氏的優點亦是真。最終要看樓主認為那樣更重要了。

bebebe12345

bebebe12345 發表於 12-9-8 11:01
孩子多大了、準備轉聲未,如果真的喜歡Vocal.....不要太心急、唱壞了不能再回頭。讓他參加學校的Choir足矣, ...

那就可以一點也不急了。以方便為主!